Tuesday, Aug 27: Albion River Bridge — Community Meeting and Public Comment Workshop

WHAT:

An informal workshop aimed at providing more information about Caltrans’ proposed Albion River Bridge project.

WHO:

Presented by Albion Bridge Stewards, with experts on historic and environmental preservation and coastal land use policies. 

WHY:

Caltrans’ so-called “public meeting” earlier this month was very one-sided, with lengthy presentations that left little time for Q&A. Worse, the meeting facilitator refused to extend the meeting to accommodate the many raised hands in the room.

We think the community should hear the full story.

We’ll start with a short presentation, and then assist community members who would like to comment on Caltrans’ plans. (Public comment is due by September 9.)

WHERE:

Mendocino Community Center in Mendocino

WHEN:

Tuesday, August 27.

The meeting begins at 5:30, but anyone is welcome to drop in any time between 5:30 and 8 pm.

Refreshments will be served.

Caltran’s DEIS/DEIR Meeting: Lots of Questions, Few Answers

Along with more than 100 other concerned members of the public, we attended Caltrans’ standing-room-only meeting concerning the draft environmental impact statement and draft environmental impact report (DEIS/DEIR).

Our bridge banner greeted attendees of the Caltrans meeting.

In our previous post, we outlined just some of our concerns with the proposed Albion River Bridge replacement project (starting with the fact that this proposed project used to include the word rehabilitation). Caltrans’ meeting only added to our concerns—attendees asked many questions that were met with answers like “we don’t know yet” or “that depends” or “that will be determined later.”

It’s hard to comment with specifics on plans that are vague.

Despite many still-raised hands, Caltrans ended the meeting promptly at 7:30 pm. When we suggested the meeting be extended, the meeting facilitator refused, noting simply that ”we’re hearing your feedback.” Implied in that response: “But we’re ignoring it.”

Here’s a short news report on the meeting that ran on KZYX, Mendocino County Public Broadcasting.

Here’s the recording of the meeting itself.

What’s Next: August 27 Community Commenting Meeting

On August 27, we will host a community commenting meeting aimed at enabling anyone concerned about Caltrans’ plans to provide public comment, which is due to the agency by September 9.

We’ll share more information about this important meeting this week.

What you should know about Caltrans’ latest plans

We’ve created a flyer that briefly outlines the worst aspects of Caltrans’ proposed plans for destroying the historic Albion River Bridge.

Here’s the text of the flyer and accompanying map. You can also download a PDF of the flyer.

Caltrans plans to alter the Albion coast, destroying a piece of history and impacting the coastal environment and economy — for no good reason

Caltrans and the US Federal Highway  Administration propose to spend roughly $150 million of taxpayer money to destroy Albion’s iconic and historic Albion River Bridge.

Caltrans’ plans would create a wider, faster, out-of-place concrete bridge ­­— where the county, state, and federal law and coastal plans for our area specifically prohibit it.

Three to five years of construction, massive cut-and-fill grading, lane and road closures, and environmentally damaging noise and nighttime lighting

• Thousands of partial and full closure hours of Highway 1, with a 126-mile detour via Highway 101 (or by poorly maintained, low-capacity county roads, 28 miles)

• Closure of the wild and scenic Albion River to commercial fishing and recreational boats, including to build cofferdams in the estuarine river

• Closure of the Albion Flats campground and public recreational access to Albion Cove Beach

• Large, unsightly retaining walls along Highway 1 and on the unstable bluffs

• Substantial construction noise, vibrations from pile driving, and dust from grading

• Construction of haul roads through south and north Albion and down the North Side and South Side Albion River bluffs (see map below)

• Construction of two nearly 1000-foot-long, 50-foot-wide trestles (both sides of the existing bridge) and two other possible trestles off the north and south Albion River bluffs 

• Removal of trees and other major vegetation from the Albion River and Albion Cove bluffs, with subsequent erosion

• Mass cut-and-fill grading of some 450,000 cubic feet, with potentially 3,300 dump truck round trips (including removal of the Albion River Bridge)

• A bridge concept that is 81 percent wider than the existing bridge, and would cast shade over substantial eelgrass, beach, dune, bluff, and Albion Flats recreational areas

• Cumulative impacts from more than twenty other Highway 1 projects that stall travel to work, schools, stores, medical providers, and the hotels, inns, restaurants, and parks in our critical county coastal economy

Granite Construction: a dubious reputation

For this expensive and unnecessary project, Caltrans has tapped a design-build contractor with a history of environmental, worker safety, and financial violations (for a full list, go to tinyurl.com/ARBgranite).

The company has been fined more than $22 million since 2000 alone — a sordid mix of accounting violations ($12 million), competition-related offenses ($8.25 million), environmental offenses ($1.07 million), government contracting violations ($367,000), and safety violations ($354,633).

Is this a company we want anywhere near a state-designated Wild and Scenic River?

The solution: maintain and preserve

The answer is simple: tell Caltrans to maintain and preserve this historic bridge — and the beautiful environment that surrounds it.

Other states have proven the durability and economic benefits of timber bridges; Minnesota has more than 1700 timber bridges of all sizes and a robust system of inspection and maintenance (to learn more, search for “minnesota timber bridges”).

If Minnesota can do it, California can, too.

Join us and learn what you can do

Public comment on the latest plans is due on or before September 9. Submit your comments in writing no later than September 9, 2024, to Caltrans, Liza Walker, North Region
Environmental, 1656 Union Street, Eureka, CA 95501, or albionbridge@dot.ca.gov.

And don’t forget to attend the meeting on August 13 at 6 pm at the Whitesboro Grange, 32510 Navarro Ridge Rd., Albion.

Video of September 20, 2018 Caltrans Public Scoping Meeting: Salmon Creek Bridge Replacement Project

Here’s the video of a Caltrans public scoping meeting held at the Albion School on September 11, 2018 for a proposed replacement of the Salmon Creek Bridge.

(Caltrans held two scoping meetings for this project because members of the local Jewish community expressed concern that the September 11 meeting had been scheduled for the Jewish holiday of Rosh Hashanah.)

Video of Caltrans Informational Meeting, April 17, 2018

Here’s the video of an information meeting held at the Albion School on May 17, 2018.

The primary subject is a proposed geotechnical investigation that will involve extensive tree removal and grading just north of the Albion River Bridge. After that, drilling platforms and rigs will be lowered into place by what Caltrans described as “Huey helicopters.”

May 9 Caltrans meeting in Albion to discuss Community Impact Assessment for bridge projects

Submitted by Frank Demling, Caltrans project manager

Caltrans and their environmental consultant, ICF, have reserved the Albion Ridge Elementary School for Tuesday, May 9, 2017 from 6:00 P.M. to 8:00 P.M. to meet with the local community to discuss the Community Impact Assessment (CIA) for the Albion River and Salmon Creek bridge projects.

The CIA is an iterative process that will assist in the planning, project development, and decision making throughout the life of both projects. The CIA will include an analysis of the potential impacts that each project alternative would have on the community and identify opportunities to avoid, minimize, and /or mitigate any adverse effects from each alternative.

Public involvement is an integral part of the CIA process and we hope that as many community members as possible will be able to attend this very important meeting.

Please feel free to submit your questions, comments and concerns, as well as any topics you would care to discuss relative to the CIA process, for the open discussion portion of the meeting.

You may contact Liza Walker, Senior Environmental Planner, at (530) 741-4139, email liza.walker@dot.ca.gov or Frank Demling, Project Manager, (707) 445-6554, frank.demling@dot.ca.gov if you have further questions.

Draft meeting agenda as follows:

  • Project Descriptions
  • Salmon Creek Project Alternatives
  • Albion River Project Alternatives
  • Environmental Documents
  • Salmon Creek Project Initial Study / Environmental Assessment
  • Process and Opportunities for Input
  • Albion River Project Environmental Impact Report / Environmental Assessment
  • Process and Opportunities for Input
  • Review Environmental Resource Categories
  • Community Impact Assessment (CIA)
  • Project Location
  • CIA Study Area
  • General Plan Land Use Designations
  • Zoning
  • Farmland/Timberland
  • Community Resources
  • Request Public Input Regarding Community Resources
  • Open Discussion